Every product is selected independently by our editors. Things you buy through our links may earn us a little commission. Learn more
You are very serious before your shaving. You gather all necessary things — shaving cream, razor, blades, or gel. But, many men are not careful about their aftershave skincare. Just they splash and rinse off their face and dab some general moisturizers. But, you need some strong products that can quickly recover, soothe, and hydrate your post-shaved skin.
And if you have sensitive-prone skin; you may also experience irritation, dryness, redness, bumps, hives, or itchy skin after shaving. Don’t worry! These things no more can cause any discomfort because today there are lots of aftershave lotions that can calm, nourish, and tone your skin immediately.
Below, I will show the 10 best aftershave lotions for those who own sensitive skin and want relief within seconds after shaving. These gentle, moisturizing, and mitigating aftershave lotions will calm you faster from razor burns, cuts, bumps, nicks, ingrown hairs, itchy skin, redness, and tightness.
These lotions are specially developed for men’s post-shave sensitive, rough, tight, and dry skin. These products also contain natural, organic, safe, and skin-friendly ingredients that will cut off all your skin flare-ups (EVEN ACNE-CAUSING BACTERIA) leaving the skin smooth, healed, and nourished.
Keep reading on, hope you will not be disappointed.
1. Proraso After Shave Lotion
Best Relaxing
Its skin relaxing ingredients are menthol, witch hazel, and eucalyptus oils. Apply the lotion after shaving to soothe, refresh, and hydrate the skin.
It cleanses, tones, and calms the skin immediately. Witch hazel reduces inflammation, rashes, and redness. Eucalyptus purifies your skin. And menthol cools, revitalizes, and soothes sensitiveness.
95% natural ingredients, made in Italy, and no colors added. Proraso After Shave Lotion is ideal for all men with all skin types.
2. Every Man Jack Post Shave Face Lotion
Best Soothing
This aftershave lotion used aloe vera, vitamin E, peppermint oil, and signature mint that work amazingly for itchy dry tight skin though guys with any skin type can also use it.
It provides your aftershave skin with day-long hydration. This non-greasy lightweight lotion heals razor-irritated skin without clogging pores and prevents acne formation.
Every Man Jack Post Shave Lotion contains plant-based and naturally-derived ingredients that ensure the safety of your skin. Made in the USA and no cruelty, paraben, color, scent, or not tested on animals.
3. Gillette After Shave Lotion for Sensitive Skin
Best Non-Greasy Formula
Oats and glycerin are amazing skin-soothing and moisturizing ingredients. This lotion contains non-greasy emollients that eliminate dryness, tightness and burning of the skin leaving a matte finished look.
A perfect post-shave lotion for sensitive, dry, and aging skin. My brother, Robin uses it after his shaving to reduce his razor irritation.
He says Gillette After Shave Lotion stings slightly meaning it is calming his skin. This lotion also helps soothe his razor bumps, itchiness, redness, hives, ingrown hairs, and minor cuts.
4. Nivea Men Body Shaving After-Shave Lotion
Best for Face & Body
Many of our readers like its ingredients much – vitamin B, aloe vera, and menthol. It is a maximum hydrating post-shave balm for the face and body.
Nivea Men Body Shaving After-Shave Lotion absorbs quickly and makes the skin smooth. It protects and smooths out the skin and reduces post-shaved irritation.
No tight, dry, or chafed skin. It is also a great moisturizer for winter to keep the post-shave skin smooth without stickiness.
5. Leovard Unscented After Shave Lotion
Best Anti-Aging
Aloe, green tea, turmeric, witch hazel, white willow, salicylic acid, chamomile, English lavender, and ginger are its anti-aging, hydrating, antibacterial, and brightening ingredients.
Use this luxury lotion to soothe your post-shaved skin. It conditions tight skin, reduces razor burns & bumps, treats blemishes, prevents aging signs, and gets rid of ingrown hairs.
Leovard Unscented After Shave Lotion contains antioxidants, essential oils, and other potent properties that heal inflammation and irritation.
6. Lubriderm Men’s 3-In-1 Lotion
Best Dermatologist-Suggested
This aftershave gel is rich in aloe vera, titanium dioxide, and essential minerals. It is a dermatologist-developed and unscented lotion for face, body, and post-shave skin.
Its triple-action formula soothes, moisturizes, and improves your skin’s texture. Aloe vera calms, heals, and hydrates razor-burnt skin.
A fast-absorbing and lightweight formula for dry, sensitive, oily, or combination skin. Its potent minerals and hydrators improve your healthy-looking skin.
7. Gabels Bay Rum After Shave Lotion
Best Masculine Scented
It is just an amazing aftershave lotion because of containing The Virgin Islands’ Original Bay Rum oils that dramatically soften and calm the skin.
One Amazon user said, “I am astonished by this bay rum aftershave, it is actually a good smelling and refreshing aftershave. It has the burning, tightening, and toning of the face after a close shave. The scent isn’t gone before you can get out of the house. Also, the scent isn’t overpowering, but lingers in a good refreshing way.”
8. MAN INC Aftershave Lotion for Sensitive Skin
Best Antioxidant-Rich
This grooming item is packed with antioxidants, brightening, conditioning, and healing ingredients like willow bark, vitamin C, amino acids, chamomile, vitamin E, and green tea.
MAN INC Aftershave Lotion fades off wrinkles, lightens scars, protects free radicals, reduces ingrown hairs, and soothes razor bumps & burns.
This lotion helps renew tones & textures, treat blemishes, diminish hyperpigmentation, and prevent environmental damages too. This smelling lotion is blended with natural scents of menthol, cedarwood, and sandalwood.
9. Afta After Shave Skin Conditioner
Best for Dry Skin
“I have ever seen so effective aftershave”, said one of my male colleagues. He also mentioned that this lotion is very gentle on his dry & sensitive skin.
It gives a clean and fresh smell without overwhelming and makes his facial skin feeling comfortable all day long. Afta After Shave Skin Conditioner soothes his skin either it is a razor, blade, or electric razor burn.
Its fresh scent stays longer, fresh, and natural like you are staying in the 80s woods. It also helps hydrate and soften his tight skin.
10. KOHANA Post Shave Lotion
Best Overall Lotion
This aftershave balm is formulated with some invigorating, moisturizing, and soothing ingredients like vitamin E, shea butter, chamomile, calendula, menthol, black walnut, and lemon peel extracts.
It is alcohol-free, unscented, and contains all-natural ingredients that soften, soothe, and refresh the skin after shaving. KOHANA Post Shave Lotion gently soothes razor burns, irritation, and cuts.
This lotion also heals your burnt skin quickly. Made in USA, not tested on animals, healthy for skin conditions, and no dye, paraben, or sulfate.
How to choose a good quality aftershave lotion?
Your skin may be either dry sensitive or oily sensitive. Dryness, tightness, redness, inflammation, and rashes are common flare-ups with sensitive skin. And if you have oily-sensitive skin then you may also experience oils, acne, or blackheads. Consider the following things in buying an aftershave lotion for sensitive skin then you will be benefited more:
Gentle Formula: The formula should be gentle like menthol, aloe, mint, chamomile, eucalyptus, and oats that can soothe, sting, and calm down the skin.
Dry Skin: Consider shea butter, vitamin E, essential oils, glycerin, hyaluronic acid, or organic moisturizers that can hydrate, nourish, and soften your dryness and tightness associated with the post-shave skin.
Oily Skin: Consider vitamin C, green tea extracts, lemon peel, salicylic acid, witch hazel, turmeric, aloe, etc. These ingredients are effective for oily skin, blemishes, and acne. Vitamin C dries out excess oils and acne-causing bacteria. Turmeric is an antiseptic that heals skin.
Soothing Masculine Scent: And a light clean smell in your lotion can be a bonus. But, it won’t interfere with your cologne. To get a natural and right level of scent, read the product label for mint, cedarwood, sandalwood, clove, cinnamon, peppermint, etc. These scents cause manly feelings.
Actually, you know better what ingredients you should include in your products.
Common signs of sensitive skin
If your skin reacts to various conditions or a product or any ingredients, you may have sensitive skin. Your skin may be reacted with serious allergens to eczema or rosacea. And if those reactions continue, you have persistent sensitive skin. Other symptoms are:
Redness, flushes, bumps, rashes, burning, stinging, irritation, itchy skin, eczema, dry patches, flakes, scaling, broken capillaries on cheeks and nose, and even your skin can break out easily with excess oils, acne, and blackheads.
Bad weather like cold or windy days your skin may be reacted with swollen blood vessels, allergies, or rosacea. Products with pungent or artificial scents may trigger your skin. And sensitive skin easily may be burnt by the sun rays.
Don’t forget to see your doctor or a dermatologist if you have any serious skin condition.
DIY tips to manage your sensitive skin
Try to avoid the things that may flare up your skin. Like — protecting your skin from the rough weather, using broad-spectrum sunscreen to reverse the harmful effects of the sun, choosing natural scent-based products or therapeutic essential oils, using ceramide-based moisturizer, lukewarm water, and gentle cleanser will protect your skin from itchiness.
Choose hypoallergenic products that can reduce the burning and stinging effects on the skin. And if you have dry patches, scales or flakes, or eczema then topical steroid or over-the-counter products will be helpful. Always, keep your skin clean, moisturized, and fresh. Finally, all products should be gentle.
How to apply an aftershave lotion perfectly?
After shaving, rinse off your face with cold water and pat the skin dry. Then take some lotion on your right-hand palm and spread it on your both palms and dab your palms gently onto your face, neck, and all over the shaving area. Don’t allow the eye area. Use a moisturizer if you need it. Your lotion may sting the skin that means it is working and soothing the skin.
To be more groomed, you can also watch this video – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqDm2utROHI
Wrapping Up
Care your skin equally before and after shaving. It will ensure perfect smoothing and soothing skin. These aftershave lotions, balms, and gels for sensitive skin are usable daily, help prevent dry skin, treat acne, reduce wrinkles, and give you masculine scented skin all day long.
After using lotion, you can also spray some moisturizer for extra smooth skin or can choose an aftershave balm (it is more hydrating). All these things will also prevent premature aging, dark spots, and hyperpigmentation. Just boom up!:)
